← Articles
StoriesThe Night SkyNovember 2026

Heads or Tails: The Coin Toss Before the Day the Music Died

A true story, retold with the sky of its day, for reflection. It is not a prediction.

In February 1959, a coin toss gave Ritchie Valens the last seat on Buddy Holly's small plane. Here is the sky over snowy Iowa that night.

A snowy field at night under many stars, an old fence and a bare tree

Cold Buses and a Coin

Nothing glamorous put three young rock and roll stars on a small plane in northern Iowa. It started with broken heaters and dirty laundry. The "Winter Dance Party" tour had opened in Milwaukee on January 23, 1959, and it was booked into a different Midwestern town almost every night. The old tour buses kept breaking down, and their heaters failed in the deep cold. On February 1, after a bus broke down in the snow, Buddy Holly's drummer, Carl Bunch, was taken to hospital with frostbite in both feet.

On Monday, February 2, the tour played the Surf Ballroom in Clear Lake, Iowa. Holly, tired of the buses, decided to hire a small plane. The ballroom's owner phoned Dwyer's Flying Service at the airport in nearby Mason City for him. The four-seat Beechcraft Bonanza would cost $36 for each passenger. It would fly to Fargo, North Dakota, the nearest airport to the next show in Moorhead, Minnesota. Holly wanted time to rest and to get his laundry done.

Then the seats changed hands. Holly's bass player, Waylon Jennings, gave his seat to J.P. "The Big Bopper" Richardson, who had the flu. Holly's guitarist, Tommy Allsup, had the other seat. Ritchie Valens, 17, asked him for it, and they settled it with the toss of a coin. Valens won.

Valens was afraid of flying. In January 1957, two planes had collided over his junior high school in Pacoima, California, and wreckage fell onto the schoolyard. He was not at school that day; he was at his grandfather's funeral. But he had nightmares about it for a long time after. A popular story says that after the coin toss he joked it was the first time he had ever won anything. Nobody can be sure he said it, and people who were there remember the toss in different ways, even who flipped the coin.

Before Holly left, he and Jennings swapped a joke. Holly said he hoped Jennings's bus froze up again. Jennings joked back that he hoped Holly's plane crashed. Jennings said later that those words stayed with him for many years.

Five Miles Into the Dark

The pilot was Roger Peterson, a 21-year-old local pilot. The plane took off from Mason City at 12:55 AM on Tuesday, February 3, 1959, from runway 17. Light snow was falling, the clouds were getting lower, and the wind was strong.

The Civil Aeronautics Board later looked closely at that night. It found that the flight needed a pilot who could fly by instruments alone, and Peterson had not yet passed that test: he had failed an instrument flight check nine months earlier. It found that the weather briefing he was given had serious gaps. It also found that the plane had a Sperry attitude indicator, the dial that shows whether the nose is up or down. This model showed the nose going up and down in the opposite way from the ones he had trained on. In the dark, with no lights on the ground to guide him, that may have confused him.

At about 1:00 AM, roughly five miles northwest of the airport, the plane hit a frozen field at high speed, right wing first. Buddy Holly was 22. Ritchie Valens was 17. J.P. Richardson was 28. Roger Peterson was 21.

Two Skies: Holly's Birth and That Night

Buddy Holly was born on September 7, 1936, in Lubbock, Texas. His birth time, about 3:30 PM, comes from memory, not a birth certificate (Rodden rating A). So we look only at planets that hardly move in a few hours.

Holly's Sun was at 15 degrees of Virgo, the sign astrologers link with careful work and craft. Only about a degree and a half away sat Neptune, the planet astrologers link with dreams, music and imagination. Both made a square, a tense 90-degree angle, to Jupiter at 15 degrees of Sagittarius, the planet of big hopes. That square was less than a degree from exact. It is easy to see the picture: a careful craftsman with a dreamer's ear and big plans. He wrote many of his own songs and liked to try new sounds in the studio. The Beatles and the Rolling Stones both counted him as an early influence.

For the night of the crash, the takeoff time is on record, but the crash time is only "about 1 a.m." So we leave out the horizon and the top of the sky, which change every few minutes, and look only at the planets.

The Sun, at almost 14 degrees of Aquarius, stood opposite Uranus at 14 degrees of Leo. The gap from an exact opposition was about two-thirds of a degree. Modern astrologers link Aquarius and Uranus with flight, radio, electricity and sudden change.

Venus, the planet of song and beauty, stood at nearly 4 degrees of Pisces. She was less than half a degree from Fomalhaut, one of the four "royal stars" of later star lore, often read today as a star of dreams and high ideals. Venus was also opposite Pluto, about a quarter of a degree from exact. Astrologers read Pluto as deep, lasting change. None of this caused the crash. It is simply the sky that stood over a night many people still remember.

What Remains in the Cornfield

Tommy Allsup later named a club in Texas "Tommy's Heads Up Saloon," after the coin toss. Waylon Jennings became one of the biggest stars in country music. Near Clear Lake, a large metal sculpture of Buddy Holly's glasses marks the path to the field where the plane came down. Holly's hits all came in less than two years, yet young players are still learning his songs.

Astrology cannot predict an accident, and nothing in a chart could have changed that night. What it can do is describe the weather of a time. Knowing your own transits, the way the moving planets touch your birth chart, can help you choose how to meet each season of your life: when to rest, when to take care, when to push. If you are curious which planets stood where on the day you arrived, you can open your free birth chart below.

A note from Mike Astrology: This is a case study. We look at the sky at moments history remembers. The sky does not cause what happens, and nothing here blames or judges anyone.

We remember everyone involved with respect.

Sources: takeoff and crash times from the Civil Aeronautics Board accident report on N3794N (1959); facts from Wikipedia ("The Day the Music Died", "Winter Dance Party", "Ritchie Valens"); birth data rated A in the Rodden system (Astro-Databank data as listed by Astrotheme); sky positions from Mike Astrology's own engine.

Read My Birth Chart — Free

Free. Your birth date, time and place — that is all it needs.

Which stars stood over the night you were born?

Get Your Fixed Stars Reading — $44