← Articles
StoriesThe Sky WitnessNovember 2026

"We Are Holding Our Own": The Last Words From the Edmund Fitzgerald

A true story, retold with the sky of its day, for reflection. It is not a prediction.

At about 7:10 PM on Nov 10, 1975, the Edmund Fitzgerald radioed "We are holding our own." Minutes later she was gone. Saturn squared Uranus that night.

A dark, wave-crossed lake at night, with an old ship's bell hanging in a wooden frame on the shore, and Saturn and a small blue planet above

Seventy-Knot Gusts, Seventeen Miles From Shelter

Sailors on the Great Lakes have long spoken of the "Witch of November": the fierce autumn storms that come when cold Arctic air crashes into the last warm air of summer. Ocean hurricanes build over days. These lake storms can turn calm water wild in a few hours. Lake Superior, about 350 miles long, gives them plenty of room to grow.

On the afternoon of November 10, 1975, the 729-foot ore carrier SS Edmund Fitzgerald, the flagship of her fleet, was heading southeast toward the shelter of Whitefish Bay with 26,116 tons of taconite iron ore pellets. Her captain, Ernest McSorley, was 63, a veteran of more than forty years on the lakes, and reportedly close to retirement. Gusts topped seventy knots. Waves reached twenty-five feet, and the ship behind her was hit by rogue waves of thirty-five feet or more.

Five Calm Words and an Empty Radar Screen

About ten miles behind her, the SS Arthur M. Anderson, under Captain Jesse "Bernie" Cooper, followed through the snow. Around 3:30 that afternoon, McSorley had radioed the Anderson that he had a fence rail down, two vents lost or damaged, and a list. He said his pumps were running. Soon after, he reported that both of his radars were out and asked the Anderson to keep track of him. Later he told the captain of another ship, the Avafors, that it was one of the worst seas he had ever been in.

At about 7:10 PM Eastern Standard Time, the Anderson's first mate, Morgan Clark, asked McSorley how they were making out with their problems. McSorley answered in five steady words: "We are holding our own." Around 7:15, the Fitzgerald's dot faded from the Anderson's radar in the snow and spray, and it did not come back. When the Anderson called again a few minutes later, there was no answer. No distress call was ever sent. Searchers later found an oil slick, two empty lifeboats and other debris.

Four days later, a U.S. Navy plane picked up a magnetic signal from the wreck. Sonar and an underwater camera later showed the ship lying in two pieces, 530 feet down, about seventeen miles from the entrance to Whitefish Bay. All twenty-nine men were lost, and their bodies were never recovered.

Saturn Square Uranus in the Sky That Night

We set the sky for about 7:10 PM Eastern Standard Time, the time of the last radio call, at the wreck site (46°59.9'N, 85°06.6'W). No one knows the exact minute the ship went down, so we do not read the horizon or the houses here. We read only planets and stars, and we checked that each contact below holds from 7:00 to 7:30 PM.

Saturn, near 3° Leo, stood in a square (a 90-degree angle) to Uranus, near 4° Scorpio, less than one degree from exact. Astrologers often read Saturn as weight, steel and heavy loads, and Uranus as sudden breaks and shocks. A square between them is traditionally read as strain between the two. Uranus was in Scorpio, a water sign.

Venus, near 1½° Libra, made a square to Mars, near 2½° Cancer, about one degree from exact. Mars was in Cancer, another water sign.

The Moon, in Aquarius, was about one degree from a square to the lunar nodes, the two points where the Moon's path crosses the Sun's path. The North Node, near 22° Scorpio, sat less than a tenth of a degree from Unukalhai, the star at the neck of the Serpent. Older astrology books give this star a harsh nature, like Saturn and Mars.

Twenty-Nine Rings of the Ship's Bell

On July 4, 1995, divers raised the Edmund Fitzgerald's bronze bell from the wreck and left a replica engraved with the names of the twenty-nine men in its place. The restored bell is now kept at the Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum at Whitefish Point. Each November 10, it rings once for each of the twenty-nine men, and once more for all sailors lost on the Great Lakes. In Detroit, the Mariners' Church holds its own service and rings its bell for them too.

We read the sky over lost ships with quiet respect for the people who worked those cold waters, and for the families who still remember them.

Astrology cannot predict a storm or a shipwreck, and nothing in a chart could have changed that night. What it can do is describe the "weather" of a time. Knowing your own transits, the way the moving planets touch your birth chart, can help you choose how to meet each season of your life: when to rest, when to take care, when to push. If you would like to see the sky on the day you were born, you can make your free birth chart below.

A note from Mike Astrology: This is a case study. We look at the sky at moments history remembers. The sky does not cause what happens, and nothing here blames or judges anyone.

We remember everyone involved with respect.

Sources: event time (last radio call, about 7:10 PM EST) from the Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum and Wikipedia; wreck position from Wikipedia; sky positions from Mike Astrology's own engine.

Read My Birth Chart — Free

Free. Your birth date, time and place — that is all it needs.

Which stars stood over the night you were born?

Get Your Fixed Stars Reading — $44